In the 2024 budget, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman introduced significant changes to property sale taxation, including the removal of indexation benefits and the reduction of Long Term Capital Gains (LTCG) tax from 20% to 12.5%. These changes are poised to impact various stakeholders in the real estate sector differently, depending on the nature and duration of their investments. Let's delve into the specifics of these changes and their expected impact on the real estate market.
Removal of Indexation Benefits:
Previously, indexation benefits allowed investors to adjust the purchase price of an asset to account for inflation, thus reducing taxable profits. With the removal of these benefits, the taxable income from property sales will likely increase, leading to higher tax liabilities for investors who hold properties for shorter durations with moderate price growth.
Reduction in LTCG Tax:
To offset the removal of indexation, the government has reduced the LTCG tax rate from 20% to 12.5%. While this aims to simplify tax computations, its impact varies based on the investment horizon and rate of property appreciation.
Shorter Duration Investments:
Global brokerage house CLSA suggests that the removal of indexation benefits will negatively impact investments held for less than five years, especially where property price appreciation is moderate (less than 10% per annum). Investors in this category may face higher tax liabilities without the inflation adjustment, making short-term property investments less attractive.
Longer Duration Investments:
For investments held over ten years, the reduced LTCG tax rate could be neutral or marginally beneficial, particularly in markets with higher price appreciation. CLSA believes markets such as Bangalore, Hyderabad, and Pune, driven by end-users, will be less affected. In contrast, investor-heavy markets like NCR and Mumbai may experience more significant impacts.
End-User Markets:
End-user-driven markets are likely to remain stable or benefit slightly from these changes. The focus on urban housing, with significant budget allocations for affordable and mid-income housing, supports demand in these areas.
Investor Markets:
Markets with higher investor activity, particularly those where properties are often sold within a few years, may see a slowdown. The combination of higher tax liabilities and reduced benefits for shorter holding periods could deter speculative investments.
Urban Housing Initiatives:
The 2024 budget also announced substantial allocations for urban housing and affordable housing schemes, aiming to support 1 crore poor and middle-class families in purchasing homes. This is expected to drive demand for residential properties and stimulate construction activities, benefiting affordable and mid-income housing players like Sobha, Prestige Estates, Sunteck Realty, and Godrej Properties.
Balancing the Market:
The changes in taxation could contribute to a more balanced real estate market. The anticipated reduction in speculative investments might lead to more stable property prices and a market driven more by end-user demand than by investors.
Tax Calculations:
To illustrate the impact of these changes, consider an example where an investor buys a property for ₹5 crore. Under the old regime, the cost of acquisition would be adjusted for inflation using the Cost Inflation Index (CII), reducing the taxable profit. With the removal of indexation, the LTCG tax at 12.5% could result in a higher tax incidence for shorter holding periods. For longer durations with significant price appreciation, the tax outcome might be neutral or slightly better.
Conclusion:
The removal of indexation benefits and the reduction of LTCG tax in Budget 2024 bring a mixed bag of outcomes for the real estate sector. While short-term investors may face higher tax burdens, the changes could promote a more stable market driven by end-user demand. The significant allocations for urban housing further underline the government's commitment to supporting the housing sector.
Comments